The Truth About Those Hotel Stars You See In Europe
Later in this post I share a few affiliate links. I may earn a commission if you click on them and make a purchase, at no cost to you. I really appreciate your support!
When you’re booking a hotel in Europe, you’ll almost always see a star rating next to the property’s name.
Five stars usually sounds luxurious, one star feels like a gamble.
BUT WHAT DO THOSE STARS REALLY MEAN?
And do they actually guarantee the kind of stay you’re imagining?
Here’s the truth: hotel star ratings in Europe can be helpful, but they don’t tell the whole story.
In some cases, they’re outdated.
It’s also worth noting that official hotel stars are completely different from the star icons you’ll see on Booking.com, Expedia, or Google reviews.
Online reviews are based on guest feedback or platform-specific formulas, while government-regulated stars are tied to checklists of services and amenities.
IN FACT, THROUGHOUT EUROPE YOU’LL OFTEN SEE A HOTEL’S OFFICIAL STAR RATING PROUDLY DISPLAYED ON EXTERIOR SIGNAGE AND EVEN PRINTED ON THEIR STATIONERY.
If you’re planning a trip, it’s worth understanding where these ratings come from, what they do (and don’t) mean, and how to interpret them to choose the best hotel for your trip.
The Truth About Those Hotel Stars You See In Europe
History of the Star Rating System
The idea of categorizing hotels by quality started in the early 20th century, when automobile associations and tourism boards wanted a simple way to guide travelers.
The Michelin Guide and AAA both used stars and diamonds as shorthand for quality, and over time, “five-star” became synonymous with luxury.
BUT HERE’S THE CATCH: THERE’S NO UNIVERSAL STANDARD.
Each country, and sometimes even each region, developed its own system.
While the general idea is consistent (more stars = more services), the actual criteria vary.
In Europe, governments or tourism boards usually regulate the ratings.
In the U.S., the system is more fragmented and often managed by private organizations or travel agencies.
Hotel Star Ratings In Europe vs. US
IN EUROPE, STAR RATINGS ARE OFTEN OFFICIAL.
Italy, Spain, France, and Germany, for example, have strict criteria: room size, bathroom facilities, reception hours, and even elevator access can make or break a star.
In the U.S., hotel ratings are less centralized.
AAA still uses diamonds, Forbes has its own list, and online travel agencies like Booking.com add to the confusion with their star-based guest reviews or internal criteria.
That means an American traveler who assumes “four stars” means the same thing everywhere is in for a surprise.
How Ratings Differ Across Countries
Even within Europe, there are differences between major countries.
France: Hotels are rated by Atout France, the country’s official tourism agency, and can earn up to five stars. A select few get the coveted “Palace” distinction: properties like Hôtel Plaza Athénée or Le Bristol Paris. This signals a level above traditional five-star luxury.
Italy: Criteria include things like multilingual staff, 24-hour reception, and room size. But a “three-star” in Rome might feel very different from a “three-star” in Sicily, because enforcement isn’t always consistent.
Germany: Uses a voluntary system managed by the Hotelstars Union, which standardizes ratings across multiple European countries (including Austria, Switzerland, and the Czech Republic). This makes stars a bit more reliable here.
United Kingdom: Ratings are managed by VisitBritain and the AA (Automobile Association), with a focus on service standards.
Outside of Europe, the waters get even muddier.
Some properties in the Middle East and Asia call themselves “six-star” or even “seven-star” hotels; the Burj Al Arab in Dubai is a famous example.
BUT THOSE RATINGS ARE PURE MARKETING, NOT PART OF ANY OFFICIAL CLASSIFICATION.
And one more clarification: don’t confuse hotel star ratings with hotel chain categories.
Marriott, Hilton, and Hyatt use categories (sometimes going as high as 8) to set how many loyalty points you need for a stay.
That has nothing to do with the government-regulated star systems in Europe.
What You Can Actually Expect From Each Star Rating
Here’s where travelers get tripped up: a star rating isn’t a promise of style or even quality.
IT’S A CHECKLIST OF FACILITIES AND SERVICES.
That’s why you might find a dull five-star convention hotel that ticks all the boxes but feels soulless, and a three-star boutique hotel that charms you with design and service.
Still, the system gives a baseline.
Here’s what you can generally expect:
1-Star Hotels: Bare Essentials
Basic room with a bed, a chair, and a sink (sometimes a shared bathroom).
Minimal front desk hours.
No frills, but usually clean and functional.
Best for: travelers who just need a place to sleep and don’t care about amenities.
2-Star Hotels: Basic Comfort
Small private rooms, usually with an en-suite bathroom.
Daily housekeeping.
Limited reception hours, possibly no elevator.
Best for: budget travelers who still want privacy and cleanliness.
3-Star Hotels: Standard Amenities
Larger rooms, often with a desk or seating area.
On-site breakfast service.
Reception staffed for longer hours.
Wi-Fi and TVs as standard.
Best for: most mid-range travelers who want comfort without overspending.
4-Star Hotels: Superior Comfort and Service
Spacious rooms with higher-quality furnishings.
24-hour reception and concierge services.
On-site restaurant(s), bar, fitness center, or business facilities.
Extras like minibars, robes, or slippers.
Best for: travelers who value amenities and service, or want a more comfortable home base.
5-Star Hotels: Luxury and Full-Service Facilities
Multiple dining options, often including fine dining.
Spa, pool, gym, and full concierge services.
High staff-to-guest ratio.
Extras like valet parking, 24-hour room service, and turndown service.
Best for: luxury seekers, special occasions, or itineraries where the hotel stay is a highlight in itself.
Does A Higher Star Always Mean A Better Experience?
Here’s the part travelers often misunderstand: stars don’t measure a hotel’s vibe.
They measure its services.
A five-star hotel may have three restaurants — but if you’ll be out exploring every night, you might never use them.
A one-star hotel may feel perfectly fine if all you need is a bed between train rides.
And in some cases, newer hotel groups push the boundaries of the rating system — for example, staffing a restaurant only during breakfast to qualify for a “restaurant” tick-box without actually running a full-service kitchen.
MY ADVICE? PAY FOR THE AMENITIES YOU’LL ACTUALLY USE.
If your itinerary has you out from morning to night, a three-star boutique hotel might be the sweet spot.
If your trip is about relaxation, say, a Tuscan villa stay or a Paris weekend with long mornings in bed — then a five-star might be worth it.
Don’t get hung up on the number of stars.
LOOK AT LOCATION, DESIGN, SERVICE STYLE, AND REVIEWS.
And remember: some of the best stays in Europe are boutique properties that prioritize charm and service over ticking every box for an extra star.
Conclusion
So, are hotel stars in Europe worth paying attention to?
Yes — but only up to a point.
They give you a baseline expectation, especially for essentials like room size and reception hours.
BUT THEY WON’T TELL YOU WHETHER A HOTEL FEELS STYLISH, HAS WARM STAFF, OR IS IN A NEIGHBORHOOD THAT MATCHES YOUR ITINERARY.
When choosing, weigh the stars against your own travel style.
If you’ll use the pool, spa, and concierge, five stars make sense.
If your hotel is just a crash pad between adventures, save your budget for experiences instead.
For more on how to actually choose the right hotel for your trip, I’ve written a full guide here: Choosing a Hotel? How to Find the Best Boutique Hotels in Europe.
Stars are a starting point, not the whole story.
Your best hotel stay in Europe will come from matching the property’s vibe and amenities to the kind of trip you want to have.
Until next time,
Angela
PLANNING A VACATION?
When you book through my links, you help support the site — at no extra cost to you.
Thanks for being a part of the Notes From Here journey! ❤️
💃 Book Tours and Experiences with Viator
🛎️ Find Hotels with Booking.com
🚗 Find a Rental Car with Discover Cars
🚅 Book a Train with RailEurope
🛡️ Get Travel Insurance with SafetyWing
🎩 Arrange Private Transfers with DayTrip
🚌 Book a Bus or Ferry with Omio